Media Release - 25 June 2025 The New Zealand International Business Forum (NZIBF) is pleased to announce the appointment of Felicity Roxburgh as its...
Right of Reply: Why Business Supports TPP – Honestly

By Stephen Jacobi
When Rod Oram said in his column last week that business leaders are being dishonest about the Trans Pacific Partnership (TPP), he was taking issue with the 28 business associations from all sectors of the economy, which signed an open letter expressing support for TPP. The letter can be found at https://www.tradeworks.org.nz/letter-to-the-prime-minister/. Public debate on TPP is important, but should be based on substance. Here are some thoughts in response.
Rod asks if TPP is an FTA? TPP eliminates tariffs on 93% of New Zealand exports to the five countries in TPP with which we do not already have FTAs (US, Japan, Canada, Mexico and Peru). That’s not 100% – much to our disappointment – but all New Zealand’s export sectors will benefit from TPP, which covers 40% of our exports – meat, dairy, kiwifruit, other horticulture, wine, wood, seafood, manufactured products including medical technologies and agricultural equipment. The extent of tariff reductions for dairy is less but dairy still benefits more than any other sector to the tune of $102 million in tariff cuts. Few, if any, FTAs have achieved complete tariff elimination at the outset. Even CER in 1983 excluded dairy products. The China FTA provides for continuing safeguard tariffs on dairy. Are these not FTAs?
Rod asks will TPP make us wealthy? He points to a New Zealand study, which he co-authored, and which finds a much lower level of economic gains for TPP than the study by Professor Anna Strutt of Waikato University available at http://www.tpp.mfat.govt.nz. Tufts University has a study, which also disputes the higher gains. A number of other international studies find results broadly similar to Professor Strutt. The difference is the methodology and assumptions, which are used in the analysis. Exporters who know their business are saying that TPP will provide better market access, lower costs and greater business opportunities. We know from past experience how FTAs deliver jobs and growth. TPP should not be any different.
Rod takes issue with the investor state dispute settlement (ISDS) rules. Business says that we need this sort of protection when, to grow the value chain and get closer to consumers, we invest in other markets where the rule of law may not be as reliable as here. New Zealand already has ISDS in other FTAs: we have never been challenged and won’t be as long as we deal fairly with foreign investors. That’s because there are safeguards, checks and balances in TPP, which uphold the Government’s continuing right to regulate on a range of matters including the environment, public health, the Treaty of Waitangi and the purchase of agricultural land.
Rod says TPP’s intellectual property rules are “US inspired”. How is it then that New Zealand has to make very few changes to our own system as a result of TPP? No change to patent terms, biologics data protection, parallel importing or use of the internet. The copyright term will be extended to 70 years after death of the author, which is already the case in the European Union and many other jurisdictions.
Rod suggests the US won’t ratify and the Chinese won’t join. He may be right. We will have to wait and see. It is interesting though to see the number of economies who have already expressed interest in joining – they include Korea, Thailand, Philippines, Taiwan, Colombia, even Indonesia. That’s because TPP is set to become the “new normal” when it comes to the rules for trade and investment.
Rod suggests that there is massive work to be done on TPP. On this, he is right. This work can be done only if New Zealand is at the table. We initiated the TPP-project in the first place. A lot of the thinking in TPP comes directly from our experience in CER. If we do not continue this work, heads may turn for a moment, but others will get on with writing the rules for international trade and investment without us. This is precisely why 28 business associations support TPP and why Helen Clark said it is “unthinkable” for New Zealand to be excluded.
Surely Rod cannot be suggesting Helen Clark is dishonest too?
Originally published in the Sunday Star-Times on 14 Feb, 2016.
REGISTER WITH TRADE WORKS
Register to stay up to date with latest news, as well as saving and discussing articles you’re interested in.
Latest News
Felicity Roxburgh Appointed Executive Director of the New Zealand International Business Forum
Media Release - 25 June 2025 The New Zealand International Business Forum (NZIBF) is pleased to announce the appointment of Felicity Roxburgh as its new Executive Director. She will officially take up the role on 7 July 2025. Felicity brings nearly two decades of...
EXECUTIVE LEADERSHIP CHANGE AT NZ INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS FORUM
Media release, 4 June 2025 Long-time trade advocate Stephen Jacobi will retire from the New Zealand International Business Forum (NZIBF) on 30 June 2025. “Stephen has made a major contribution to New Zealand’s economy and our trade interests through his articulate,...
ADDRESS TO THE 56TH ONE STOP UPDATE FOR THE ACCOUNTANT IN BUSINESS
CHRISTCHURCH AND AUCKLAND, MAY 2025 STEPHEN JACOBI, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR GLOBAL MACRO-ECONOMIC AND TRADE UPDATE My thanks as always to Brightstar for the invitation to be with you today. As some of you will know I have been a serial attender at these events, normally...
2025 APEC Ministers Responsible for Trade Joint Statement
Jeju, Republic of Korea | 16 May 2025 Read the original post here 1.We, the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Ministers Responsible for Trade (MRT), met in Jeju, Republic of Korea, from 15-16 May 2025, under the chairmanship of H.E. Inkyo Cheong, Minister of...
REMARKS TO LOCAL GOVERNMENT NZ RURAL AND PROVINCIAL SECTOR MEETING
2 MAY 2025 STEPHEN JACOBI, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR IMPACT OF TRADE WARS ON NZ My thanks to Local Government NZ for the invitation to be with you today. As a resident of Napier I am all the more pleased to contribute to this rural and provincial sector meeting. Whether you...
SUBMISSION TO THE MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND TRADE ON A COMPREHENSIVE FREE TRADE AGREEMENT WITH INDIA
April 2025 Introduction This submission is being made on behalf of the New Zealand International Business Forum (NZIBF), whose members are listed at Annex A[1]. NZIBF is a group of senior business leaders working together to promote New Zealand’s engagement in the...
LAMENTATION DAY
When President Trump spoke in the White House Rose Garden to launch his wrecking-ball “fair and reciprocal tariffs”, there were some in the audience wearing hard hats. While this was doubtless to show support for the move amongst hard-working Americans, maybe...
BUSINESS FORUM DEEPLY DISAPPOINTED WITH UNJUSTIFIED US TARIFFS
Media release, 4 April 2025 The New Zealand International Business Forum (NZIBF) has reacted with deep disappointment to the news that the United States will implement an additional 10 percent ad valorem tariff on New Zealand exports. “The United States is a close and...
Bull in a China Shop: Market Price Support in the Dairy Industry
Market price support policies (aka as “subsidies”) in the agriculture sector are a classic example of what is meant by 'beggar thy neighbour'. One country attempts to improve its own economic situation by intervening in the market on behalf of its producers, at the...
BUSINESS FORUM WELCOMES INDIA FTA NEGOTIATIONS
Media release, 17 March 2025 The NZ International Business Forum (NZIBF) welcomes the launch of free trade negotiations with India, announced in Delhi, and is particularly pleased that these will proceed on a comprehensive basis. “There is enormous value to be gained...
Playing the long trade game with India
Prime Minister Luxon is at last making his visit to India with a large business and community delegation. We wish them well in expanding and deepening the relationship with India. The reasons for doing so we have explained previously. Our Government’s...
SUBMISSION TO THE MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS AND TRADE
PROPOSED GREEN ECONOMY JOINT WORKING GROUP WITH CHILE AND SINGAPORE MARCH 2025 Introduction This submission is made on behalf of the New Zealand International Business Forum (NZIBF), whose members are listed at Annex A[1]. NZIBF is a forum of senior business leaders...
PRESENTATION TO APEC BUSINESS ADVISORY COUNCIL: ADDRESSING PROTECTIONISM AND NON TARIFF BARRIERS
BRISBANE, 24 FEBRUARY 2025 STEPHEN JACOBI, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, NZIBF My thanks to Anna Curzon and Stephanie Honey for giving me one last opportunity to speak to ABAC. I want to talk today about rising protectionism and proliferating non tariff barriers. It’s not a new...
Business Leaders Sound Alarm on Global Economic Uncertainty: Call for Unified APEC Action
Brisbane, Australia, 25 February 2025 - Among rising global economic tension, the APEC Business Advisory Council met in Brisbane this week to reaffirm its support for the value of trade and cooperation, and the original APEC commitment to free, fair, open and...
REMARKS TO FOREIGN AFFAIRS, DEFENCE AND TRADE COMMITTEE – 20 FEBRUARY 2025
RATIFICATION OF NEW ZEALAND-UAE COMPREHENSIVE ECONOMIC PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT (CEPA) STEPHEN JACOBI, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, NZIBF Thank you Chair for the opportunity to appear before the Committee today. I do so on behalf of the members of the NZ International Business...
0 Comments