Stephen Jacobi, Executive Director of NZIBF, traveled to San Francisco for APEC Leaders’ week and writes his thoughts on the outcome.
It takes 164 to tango: the 11th WTO Ministerial Meeting in Buenos Aires

In a few days’ time, Trade Ministers from the 164 WTO member-countries will meet in Buenos Aires; New Zealand Minister of Trade and Economic Growth David Parker will serve as a Vice-Chair to the Conference. It looks like it will be a struggle to emerge with new rules to address the environmental harm of ‘fish subsidies’, trade-distorting agricultural support and e-commerce (although rabbits have been pulled out of the WTO hat before today), but the rules-based multilateral trading system remains critically important to global sustainable development and prosperity, as well as to New Zealand’s.
WTO Ministers meet every two years. When the Doha Round was at its peak, these gatherings were important opportunities to resolve key inflection points in the negotiations: in 2015, for example, WTO Ministers made the historic decision to eliminate agriculture export subsidies, long a blight on the New Zealand dairy sector. This year, however, when Ministers come together from 10-13 December, prospects are looking shaky.
The most promising areas are fish subsidies, farm support and e-commerce. New Zealand has long played a leading role on the first of these – rules to prohibit the subsidies that contribute to fleet overcapacity and overfishing, especially illegal, unreported and unregulated fishing. (New Zealand has not only been active in the WTO – where talks were given new impetus by the UN Sustainable Development Goals – but also helped secure ground-breaking legally-enforceable rules in the TPP and CPTPP agreements on fish subsidies.) Despite intense efforts over the last few weeks, however, it is not certain that we will get an outcome across the line.
Likewise New Zealand has been active in seeking to curb trade-distorting agricultural subsidies – the root cause of many of the problems in the global trading system affecting Kiwi farmers as well as those from developing countries. A solution there depends on securing buy-in from the biggest developed-country spenders (the US among others) as well as concessions from large subsidising developing countries. A number of developing countries are also pushing for new rules on public food stockholding, but so far the sweet spot between designing policies to help with food shortages while not inadvertently causing harmful distortions has yet to be found. Finally, the time has clearly come for a global rules framework for e-commerce, given the exponential expansion of the digital economy, but there again, the politics may derail progress.
We are – unfortunately – well past the heyday of the Doha Round. But the Buenos Aires meeting, and the WTO system itself, still matter. After a period of dismal performance by global trade, the forecasts are looking considerably brighter; we are also seeing fewer new trade restrictions being introduced. The world is a long way from the Wild West of the pre-WTO era. But there is still a clear and present danger of a reversion to protectionism and mercantilism around the globe. The Trump Administration has made no secret of its antipathy towards the WTO (including making moves that may lead to the paralysis of the “jewel in the crown”, the WTO dispute settlement system, by refusing to appoint new judges to the Appellate Body). An outcome in Buenos Aires – even a solid future work programme – would serve as a reminder of the broad and deep benefits for all from trade liberalisation. Certainly, efforts to date have not been perfect. More needs to be done to bring along civil society and to ensure that the benefits of trade reform can be more widely shared: we need both to tell the story better, and to have a better story to tell. But to make trade work for all, we need everyone to join the dance.
This blog was prepared by NZIBF Associate Director Stephanie Honey.
REGISTER WITH TRADE WORKS
Register to stay up to date with latest news, as well as saving and discussing articles you’re interested in.
Latest News
Of APEC, CPTPP and IPEF
While New Zealand was sorting out its new Government, the alphabet soup which is trade got a good stirring in San Francisco. This was APEC Leaders’ week, the annual gathering of Leaders, Ministers, business people and other stakeholders from the 21 economies of...
Remarks to Shanghai Forum: “China and CPTPP – New Zealand Expectations and Advice”
FUNDAN UNIVERSITY, SHANGHAI, 28 OCTOBER 2023 STEPHEN JACOBI, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, NEW ZEALAND INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS FORUM 杰珂陛 执行董事 新西兰国际商业论坛 CHINA AND CPTPP – NEW ZEALAND EXPECTATIONS AND ADVICE It is an honour for me to speak in such a distinguished forum. My thanks...
ADDRESS TO THE 53rd ONE STOP UPDATE FOR THE ACCOUNTANT IN BUSINESS – GLOBAL ECONOMIC UPDATE
AUCKLAND, 16 OCTOBER 2023 STEPHEN JACOBI - EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, NZ INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS FORUM Watch the full speech here. It’s a pleasure to be back with you for the 53rd edition of the One Stop Update and my thanks to Brightstar for giving me this opportunity once...
EYES OPENED DURING INDIA VISIT
Published by Newsroom on 6 September 2023 Stephen Jacobi reports on the recent business delegation to India. Every country has its contrasts and a subcontinent of 1.4 billion with thousands of years of history has more than most. Today’s India can reach the...
GUEST BLOG: Raewyn Bleakley, Chief Executive, New Zealand Food and Grocery Council
Exporting is an important part of the business of many NZFGC members whose brands we see daily on supermarket shelves. For some, exporting outweighs what they sell on our shores, while others are looking to break into new markets to open up growth opportunities beyond...
New Zealand business delegation “over the moon” with Indian trade and investment opportunities
MEDIA RELEASE - Friday 1 September, 2023 The involvement of New Zealand businesses in the successful Indian Moon landing epitomises the trade and investment opportunities between the two countries. Just as Rakon and RocketLab provided innovative elements to the...
REMARKS TO INDIA NEW ZEALAND TRADE AND ECONOMIC ROUNDTABLE
DELHI, 28 AUGUST 2023 STEPHEN JACOBI - EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, NZ INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS FORUM Opening remarks It’s a pleasure for me and the entire New Zealand delegation to be in Delhi today just days since India’s magnificent moon landing. These days India is literally...
Large business delegation bound for India
MEDIA RELEASE - Tuesday 22 August, 2023 Fifty business representatives will leave later this week bound for Delhi, making it one of the largest delegations ever to head for India. The delegation, comprising members and senior leaders of five business organisations,...
India and New Zealand: The next innings
As published in the NZ Herald, 18 August 2023 By Stephen Jacobi As a trade mission prepares to depart for Delhi, Stephen Jacobi of the New Zealand International Business Forum considers the prospects for growing two-way trade and investment between India and New...
CRUNCH TIME FOR CPTPP
As published in the NZ Herald, 18 August 2023. By Stephen Jacobi, Executive Director, NZ International Business Forum. Following the Ministers’ meeting in Auckland, what is the outlook for CPTPP as the world’s most ambitious free trade agreement? When Ministers...
INDIA AND NEW ZEALAND: GETTING ONTO THE FRONT FOOT
A 50 person business delegation is about to depart for India. It follows a major report by the India New Zealand Business Council (INZBC), published in April. The report took a critical look at the relationship, finding a number of shortcomings and advocating...
ADDRESS TO THE HAWKE’S BAY BRANCH OF THE NZ INSTITUTE OF INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS – “TRADE SECURITY – FINDING NEW BASKETS”
TUESDAY 15 AUGUST 2023 STEPHEN JACOBI, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, NZ INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS FORUM It’s a pleasure to be with you once again. This is an address about trade but also about baskets and eggs – in particular how many eggs and how many baskets we need to prosper...
SUBMISSION TO THE PARLIAMENTARY FOREIGN AFFAIRS, DEFENCE AND TRADE COMMITTEE
INTERNATIONAL TREATY EXAMINATON OF THE NEW ZEALAND EUROPEAN UNION FREE TRADE AGREEMENT, JULY 2023 Introduction and Summary This submission is made on behalf of the New Zealand International Business Forum (NZIBF) whose members are listed at Annex A[1]. NZIBF is a...
CER CELEBRATES A RUBY ANNIVERSARY
The Australia-New Zealand Leadership, the semi-annual gathering of Ministers and business leaders, has been described as a “successful symbol of trans-Tasman togetherness[1]”. And the togetherness vibe was certainly present when the Forum gathered in Wellington...
Asia-Pacific businesses urge APEC Leaders to act on equity, sustainability and opportunity in an increasingly challenging landscape
APEC NEWS RELEASE issued by the APEC Business Advisory Council (ABAC) Meeting in Cebu, the Philippines, this week, the APEC Business Advisory Council (ABAC) stressed the need for action in an increasingly fragmented and difficult operating environment. “Our theme for...